Nonclinical precedent Request an invite

Rytelo: what flexibility did regulators accept, and why?

imetelstat · Telomerase (oligo)
Flexibility accepted
CarcinogenicityAccepted with a condition
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; ICH S9 waiver claim not accepted by FDA; mouse and rat studies required postmarketing
Why: Life expectancy of lower-risk MDS patients exceeds 5 years, so carcinogenicity assessment is warranted · Within the guideline
“Based on the literature provided by the Applicant and discussion with the clinical team, the life expectancy for patients with lower risk MDS (defined variously, but usually as low or intermediate-1 risk disease by IPSS) and ESA failure or transfusion dependency is > 5 years and carcinogenicity risk assessment is warranted for the intended patient population.”
✓ VerifiedFDA multi-discipline review, p. 42Source ↗
“To address the carcinogenicity risk assessment of imetelstat, there will be separate Post Marketing Requirements (PMRs) for carcinogenicity assessments in the mouse and rat species.”
✓ VerifiedFDA multi-discipline review, p. 42Source ↗
DARTAcceptedBeyond the letter
No fertility or pre/postnatal development studies
Why: Indication mainly in older people; little or no oral bioavailability · Other reason · Pharmacology or kinetics
“No PPND study has been submitted. This was considered acceptable based on the proposed indication which is primarily relevant for older people and that imetelstat has little or no oral bioavailability”
✓ VerifiedEMA assessment report, p. 38Source ↗
Efficacy modelVerdict not stated
No MDS xenograft or MDS cell-line studies; antitumor activity shown in other myeloid and solid tumor models
Why: No MDS-specific cell lines or mouse xenograft models exist
“No xenograft studies were conducted in MDS cells lines, and this was described by the Applicant as being due to the lack of MDS specific cell lines and mouse xenograft models.”
✓ VerifiedFDA multi-discipline review, p. 40Source ↗
SpeciesQuestioned
Many potential off-target hybridization transcripts not covered in toxicology species owing to lack of sequence homology
“Importantly though, many of the identified transcripts were not covered in the nonclinical toxicology studies due to lack of sequence homology in the toxicology species.”
✓ VerifiedEMA assessment report, p. 36Source ↗
Impurity or metaboliteQuestioned
No dedicated metabolism studies; oligonucleotide degradation metabolites not identified or characterized
“The rat data indicates that imetelstat is rapidly degraded (including in the bone marrow) but the resulting degradation metabolites have not been identified (e.g., no identification of N-1, N-2 etc. metabolites has been provided by the applicant).”
✓ VerifiedEMA assessment report, p. 36Source ↗

Same question, other oligonucleotides

Amondys 45

casimersen · DMD exon 45 (PMO)
No reproductive and developmental toxicity studies; male reproductive organs and sperm evaluated in chronic studies instead

Amvuttra

vutrisiran · TTR (siRNA)
No carcinogenicity studies at approval; rat and mouse studies deferred to postmarketing requirements

Dawnzera

donidalorsen · Prekallikrein / KLKB1 (ASO)
No rabbit embryo-fetal study with donidalorsen; DART in mice only, rabbit data leveraged from the unconjugated analogue ISIS 546254

Defitelio

defibrotide · Fragmented DNA oligonucleotides
Fertility and pre/postnatal studies only from 1970s non-GLP intramuscular rat studies; not fully reviewed

Exondys 51

eteplirsen · DMD exon 51 (PMO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; transgenic mouse and rat studies deferred to postmarketing requirements

Givlaari

givosiran · ALAS1 (siRNA)
2-year rat carcinogenicity study still ongoing at approval; only the 26-week Tg-rasH2 mouse study completed

Hibsago

bepirovirsen · HBV RNA (ASO)
No exposure margin in mouse fertility study: no adverse effects up to 0.7 times the MRHD (BSA)

Izervay

avacincaptad pegol · C5 (aptamer)
Ocular toxicity studies in rabbit and dog, species in which the aptamer has very low activity; no monkey ocular study

Kynamro

mipomersen · APOB (ASO)
Mipomersen inactive in rodents and only partly active in monkey; pivotal rodent studies added a species-specific surrogate arm

Leqvio

inclisiran · PCSK9 (siRNA)
No juvenile toxicology study

Macugen

pegaptanib · VEGF-165 (aptamer)
No carcinogenicity studies for a chronic intravitreal therapy

Onpattro

patisiran · TTR (siRNA)
No 2-year rat carcinogenicity study; 26-week TgRasH2 mouse study only

Oxlumo

lumasiran · HAO1 (siRNA)
Rat 2-year and transgenic mouse 6-month carcinogenicity studies incomplete at approval; deferred to postmarketing requirements

Qalsody

tofersen · SOD1 (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; carcinogenic potential to be assessed post-approval

Qfitlia

fitusiran · Antithrombin / SERPINC1 (siRNA)
No reproduction studies in female animals (no embryo-fetal or pre/postnatal studies); male fertility assessed within 26-week rat study

Redemplo

plozasiran · APOC3 (siRNA)
2-year rat carcinogenicity study ongoing at approval; completion to be submitted postmarketing

Rivfloza

nedosiran · LDHA (siRNA)
No carcinogenicity assessment before approval; studies deferred to postmarketing

Spinraza

nusinersen · SMN2 (ASO)
No chronic rodent toxicity study to assess systemic exposure

Tegsedi

inotersen · TTR (ASO)
2-year rat carcinogenicity study not submitted before approval; required post-marketing

Tryngolza

olezarsen · APOC3 (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies with olezarsen; lifetime mouse and rat studies of unconjugated same-sequence ASO volanesorsen relied on

Viltepso

viltolarsen · DMD exon 53 (PMO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; Tg.rasH2 mouse and two-year rat studies required as postmarketing requirements

Vitravene

fomivirsen · CMV IE2 mRNA (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies; waiver requested citing lack of meaningful systemic exposure

Vyondys 53

golodirsen · DMD exon 53 (PMO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; 26-week transgenic mouse and 2-year rat studies deferred post-approval

Wainua

eplontersen · TTR (ASO)
Carcinogenic potential not assessed at FDA approval; 26-week Tg.rasH2 mouse study made a postmarketing requirement

Waylivra

volanesorsen · APOC3 (ASO)
Mouse and rat carcinogenicity studies of limited value: high toxicity-related mortality and early termination of study groups

Zanvastro

zilganersen · GFAP (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; completion required as postmarketing requirements

Summary across all 27 oligonucleotides →