Nonclinical precedent Request an invite

Exondys 51: what flexibility did regulators accept, and why?

eteplirsen · DMD exon 51 (PMO)
Flexibility accepted
CarcinogenicityAccepted with a conditionBeyond the letter
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; transgenic mouse and rat studies deferred to postmarketing requirements
Why: DMD is life-threatening and severely disabling with no satisfactory alternative therapy · Serious disease · Rare disease / unmet need
“Carcinogenicity studies have not been conducted for eteplirsen. As agreed to by the division, carcinogenicity studies in two species would be conducted post approval as PMRs.”
✓ VerifiedFDA pharmacology/toxicology review, p. 18Source ↗
“4) DMD is a life-threatening and severely disabling disease for which no satisfactory alternative therapy exists. The sponsor’s justification is acceptable.”
✓ VerifiedFDA pharmacology/toxicology review, p. 88Source ↗
DARTAcceptedBeyond the letter
No standard reproductive and developmental studies; male fertility assessed by reproductive organ histopathology in toxicity studies
Why: Patient population is primarily male · Other reason
“Because the patient population is primarily male, standard reproductive and developmental studies were not required. To assess male fertility, the sponsor conducted a histopathological evaluation of male reproductive organs in the pivotal toxicity studies,”
✓ VerifiedFDA pharmacology/toxicology review, p. 17Source ↗
SpeciesAcceptedBeyond the letter
Pharmacology and toxicity in mdx mouse required a mouse-specific exon 23 surrogate PMO (AVI-4225)
Why: Human product cannot be tested in mdx mouse because of differences in the dystrophin gene mutation · No relevant species
“For mdx mouse, the pharmacological activity of the human product cannot be tested because of differences in the dystrophin gene mutation, requiring use of a mouse-specific PMO, exon 23 skipping AON and, therefore, resulting in a different truncated dystrophin.”
✓ VerifiedFDA pharmacology/toxicology review, p. 20Source ↗
“Overall, the nonclinical studies of eteplirsen and the mouse surrogate (AVI-4225) are adequate to support approval of the NDA, with appropriate labeling and PMRs for carcinogenicity studies in two species.”
✓ VerifiedFDA pharmacology/toxicology review, p. 21Source ↗
Safety marginAcceptedBeyond the letter
Low NOAEL exposure margins: below one in mdx mouse (surrogate) and 3.4 in monkey
Why: Highest doses tested, with minimal-to-slight toxicity, gave 17 and 20 times the anticipated human exposure · Pharmacology or kinetics
“Safety margins based on plasma (AVI-4225 or eteplirsen) exposures at the NOAELs in adult animals are low (<1 in mdx mouse, 3.4 in monkey); however, plasma exposures at the highest doses tested, which were associated with minimal-to-slight toxicity (except for moderate dilatation of lateral ventricles), were 17 and 20 times the anticipated human exposure.”
✓ VerifiedFDA pharmacology/toxicology review, p. 20Source ↗

Same question, other oligonucleotides

Amondys 45

casimersen · DMD exon 45 (PMO)
No reproductive and developmental toxicity studies; male reproductive organs and sperm evaluated in chronic studies instead

Amvuttra

vutrisiran · TTR (siRNA)
No carcinogenicity studies at approval; rat and mouse studies deferred to postmarketing requirements

Dawnzera

donidalorsen · Prekallikrein / KLKB1 (ASO)
No rabbit embryo-fetal study with donidalorsen; DART in mice only, rabbit data leveraged from the unconjugated analogue ISIS 546254

Defitelio

defibrotide · Fragmented DNA oligonucleotides
Fertility and pre/postnatal studies only from 1970s non-GLP intramuscular rat studies; not fully reviewed

Givlaari

givosiran · ALAS1 (siRNA)
2-year rat carcinogenicity study still ongoing at approval; only the 26-week Tg-rasH2 mouse study completed

Hibsago

bepirovirsen · HBV RNA (ASO)
No exposure margin in mouse fertility study: no adverse effects up to 0.7 times the MRHD (BSA)

Izervay

avacincaptad pegol · C5 (aptamer)
Ocular toxicity studies in rabbit and dog, species in which the aptamer has very low activity; no monkey ocular study

Kynamro

mipomersen · APOB (ASO)
Mipomersen inactive in rodents and only partly active in monkey; pivotal rodent studies added a species-specific surrogate arm

Leqvio

inclisiran · PCSK9 (siRNA)
No juvenile toxicology study

Macugen

pegaptanib · VEGF-165 (aptamer)
No carcinogenicity studies for a chronic intravitreal therapy

Onpattro

patisiran · TTR (siRNA)
No 2-year rat carcinogenicity study; 26-week TgRasH2 mouse study only

Oxlumo

lumasiran · HAO1 (siRNA)
Rat 2-year and transgenic mouse 6-month carcinogenicity studies incomplete at approval; deferred to postmarketing requirements

Qalsody

tofersen · SOD1 (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; carcinogenic potential to be assessed post-approval

Qfitlia

fitusiran · Antithrombin / SERPINC1 (siRNA)
No reproduction studies in female animals (no embryo-fetal or pre/postnatal studies); male fertility assessed within 26-week rat study

Redemplo

plozasiran · APOC3 (siRNA)
2-year rat carcinogenicity study ongoing at approval; completion to be submitted postmarketing

Rivfloza

nedosiran · LDHA (siRNA)
No carcinogenicity assessment before approval; studies deferred to postmarketing

Rytelo

imetelstat · Telomerase (oligo)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; ICH S9 waiver claim not accepted by FDA; mouse and rat studies required postmarketing

Spinraza

nusinersen · SMN2 (ASO)
No chronic rodent toxicity study to assess systemic exposure

Tegsedi

inotersen · TTR (ASO)
2-year rat carcinogenicity study not submitted before approval; required post-marketing

Tryngolza

olezarsen · APOC3 (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies with olezarsen; lifetime mouse and rat studies of unconjugated same-sequence ASO volanesorsen relied on

Viltepso

viltolarsen · DMD exon 53 (PMO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; Tg.rasH2 mouse and two-year rat studies required as postmarketing requirements

Vitravene

fomivirsen · CMV IE2 mRNA (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies; waiver requested citing lack of meaningful systemic exposure

Vyondys 53

golodirsen · DMD exon 53 (PMO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; 26-week transgenic mouse and 2-year rat studies deferred post-approval

Wainua

eplontersen · TTR (ASO)
Carcinogenic potential not assessed at FDA approval; 26-week Tg.rasH2 mouse study made a postmarketing requirement

Waylivra

volanesorsen · APOC3 (ASO)
Mouse and rat carcinogenicity studies of limited value: high toxicity-related mortality and early termination of study groups

Zanvastro

zilganersen · GFAP (ASO)
No carcinogenicity studies before approval; completion required as postmarketing requirements

Summary across all 27 oligonucleotides →